2025 NETBALL SUPER LEAGUE

2025 NETBALL SUPER LEAGUE2024-07-02T23:24:53+10:00
Viewing 15 posts - 271 through 285 (of 285 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Avatar photoIan Harkin
    Moderator
      Post count: 25149

      Jinxibo
      Participant
        Post count: 1395

        Gabby Marshall

        ‘Two concussions in a month was scary and it’s why I’m retiring’ – https://www.bbc.com/sport/netball/articles/c77n74d6mzeo

        Avatar photoIan Harkin
        Moderator
          Post count: 25149
          Avatar photoIan Harkin
          Moderator
            Post count: 25149
            Avatar photoIan Harkin
            Moderator
              Post count: 25149

              Interesting that the NSL statement doesn’t say whether the decision was actually correct or not. They just say that it can’t be changed, so can we gather from that, that the decision wasn’t correct?

              Fluffy
              Participant
                Post count: 262

                Joyce clearly landed in the 2 point zone so I’d say yes!

                Avatar photoIan Harkin
                Moderator
                  Post count: 25149
                  Jinxibo
                  Participant
                    Post count: 1395

                    I haven’t re-watched panthers/Rhinos yet. At the time I thought it was a 2point shot but from the NSL statement I’m assuming the umpire didn’t call it as a “2”

                    The wording is strange, the committee cannot change an umpires on court decision in respect to world netball rules. So…the world netball rules cover a 2 point shot??
                    Or
                    World netball rules say umpires decision is final ??

                    Have to admit I didn’t think they would change it as this would open the flood gates for other decisions made during a games to be appealed

                    Avatar photoIan Harkin
                    Moderator
                      Post count: 25149

                      Yeah, the World Netball rules say that the umpires’ decision on court is final.

                      I watched it. Joyce certainly appears to take the ball in the SS zone, but another player obscures your view while she’s taking the shot. And yes, the umpire signals just a one-pointer. So that could have been a mistake, but what made it worse for Rhinos was that despite the umpire signalling 1, the stadium scoreboard went up by 2. So Rhinos played out time thinking they had one more point than they did.

                      It’s all a big mess that hopefully doesn’t happen again.

                      Avatar photoIan Harkin
                      Moderator
                        Post count: 25149

                        Avatar photoIan Harkin
                        Moderator
                          Post count: 25149

                          Avatar photoIan Harkin
                          Moderator
                            Post count: 25149

                            POTM in the games today: Indya Masser and Funmi Fadoju

                            Avatar photoIan Harkin
                            Moderator
                              Post count: 25149
                              Avatar photoIan Harkin
                              Moderator
                                Post count: 25149
                                Avatar photoIan Harkin
                                Moderator
                                  Post count: 25149

                                Viewing 15 posts - 271 through 285 (of 285 total)
                                • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
                                Go to Top